Traffic:   68 Incidents
Weather: 75°F Go
  03:12pm EDT, 08/08/08
Search:    1010wins.com  Web  Audio
Local News

Posted: Wednesday, 02 April 2008 5:46PM

Judge Tosses Out 'Borat' Lawsuit by N.Y. Businessman

NEW YORK (AP)  -- A judge has tossed out a defamation lawsuit brought by a businessman shown in the movie ``Borat'' as he is chased down Manhattan's Fifth Avenue by comedian Sacha Baron Cohen.

The 2006 hit, starring Cohen as a crass Kazakhstan journalist, can be deemed ``newsworthy,'' defined in its most liberal and far-reaching terms, U.S. District Judge Loretta A. Preska said.

New York civil rights law provides limited protection for any person whose image is used for advertising or trade purposes without his written consent, she said, and the nonconsensual use of a person's image to depict newsworthy events or matters of public interest is exempt from the law.

The lawsuit had sought unspecified damages from the movie's producer, Twentieth Century Fox, for Jeffrey Lemerond, who claimed he was humiliated when the Borat character tried to catch him.

In the movie, Lemerond, a Dartmouth College graduate and financial analyst, is shown running and yelling ``Go away!'' as Borat chases him in an attempt to hug strangers.

The judge conceded that the movie ``employs as its chief medium a brand of humor that appeals to the most childish and vulgar in its viewers.'' But she said the movie, ``Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan,'' also attempts an ironic commentary.

``The movie challenges its viewers to confront, not only the bizarre and offensive Borat character himself, but the equally bizarre and offensive reactions he elicits from `average' Americans,''' she wrote.

Lemerond lawyer Eric Hecker said the ruling would be appealed.

``We think New York law is clear that a corporation like Twentieth Century Fox is not entitled to pluck an otherwise anonymous citizen out of a crowd and subject him to public humiliation in order to make a buck,'' he said.

A telephone message left with a spokesman for Twentieth Century Fox was not immediately returned Wednesday.

Lemerond's lawsuit, filed last year, said he suffered ``public ridicule, degradation and humiliation'' because of his appearance in the film.

The lawsuit alleged that Twentieth Century Fox knew it was unlawful to use the footage of Lemerond without his consent because it scrambled his face in a trailer for the movie.

In deciding the case Monday, the judge wrote that courts considering whether something is newsworthy must consider solely the content rather than the publisher's motive to produce a profit.

She also said courts should be wary of replacing the editorial judgment of the media in deciding what is newsworthy or of public interest.

In the movie, Borat clashes with American culture as he travels across the country in search of Pamela Anderson.

The film has led to several lawsuits from those who claimed they were duped into appearing in it. Others who have filed suits have included South Carolina fraternity members, a Maryland driving instructor, Romanian villagers and an etiquette teacher.

More Entertainment news...


(TM & Copyright 2008 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO & EYE Logo TM & Copyright 2008 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report. In the interest of timeliness, this story is fed directly from the newswire and may contain occasional typographical errors.)
 
 
Print Page Email This Page
Featured Audio
Bruckner Expressway Nightmare
A dump truck struck a foot bridge over the Bruckner Expressway in the Bronx Friday morning causing traffic headaches for hours.
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
News Watch
All Eyes On Beijing
PIC: Truck Crash Causes Traffic Nightmare in Bronx
Bosnian Men Accused in Upstate Beating Out on Bail
2 White Men Plead Guilty in Westchester Cross Burn
Man Falls Through Subway Grate in Brooklyn
VIDEO/PIC: Bloomberg Gives Favre Warm Welcome
Bouncer Choked by Bar Patron in Critical Condition
Nassau County Dept. of Health Closes 10 Beaches
Big Apple vs. Big Ben? Study Compares Both Cities
S.I. Couple Accused of Shoplifting Lots of Scotch