Traffic:   26 Incidents
Weather: 59°F Go
  03:19am EDT, 10/14/08
Search:    1010wins.com  Web  Audio
Local News

Posted: Tuesday, 02 October 2007 7:28PM

Jury: Isiah Thomas Harassed Executive, but Team Should Pay

NEW YORK (AP)  -- In an end to a salacious three-week trial, a jury ordered the owners of the New York Knicks to pay $11.6 million to a former team executive who endured crude insults and unwanted advances from coach Isiah Thomas.

1010 WINS AUDIO: Thomas Speaks After Ruling

The jury of four women and three men found Thomas and Madison Square Garden sexually harassed Anucha Browne Sanders, but it decided only MSG and chairman James Dolan should pay for harassing and firing Browne Sanders from her $260,000-a-year job out of spite.

Agree with jury's ruling? SOUND OFF below

The result: The Garden owes $6 million for condoning a hostile work environment and $2.6 million for retaliation. Dolan owes $3 million. Though Thomas is off the hook for any damages, he leaves the case with a tarnished image.

1010 WINS AUDIO: Jury Grants Browne Sanders $11.6M

Outside court, a beaming Browne Sanders insisted her victory was more about sending a message than the money.

"What I did here, I did for every working woman in America,'' she said. "And that includes everyone who gets up and goes to work in the morning, everyone working in a corporate environment.''

Earlier, Thomas emerged from the federal courthouse in lower Manhattan with his trademark smile but flashed anger as he reasserted his innocence amid a crush of reporters and cameras.

"I'm extremely disappointed that the jury did not see the facts in this case,'' he said. "I will appeal this, and I remain confident in the man that I am and what I stand for and the family that I have.''

MSG said it will appeal, also denying wrongdoing in a case widely viewed as a public relations disaster for a franchise struggling to regain credibility. The team hasn't won a playoff game since Thomas was signed as president in December 2003 and has wasted millions this decade on a series of free-agent busts.

1010 WINS VIDEO: Isiah Thomas Found Guilty of Sexual Harassment

The verdict also amounts to another blemish on the resume of Thomas, a two-time NBA champion whose post-playing career has been marked by one failure after another.

NBA spokesman Tim Frank said the league's policies "do not encompass civil litigation.''

Jurors, who needed roughly two days to decide on the allegations but only about an hour to determine damages, declined to talk about the verdict or how they came to their decision.

In a lawsuit filed last January, the 44-year-old Browne Sanders sought $10 million in punitive damages, but the jury was free to deviate from that figure. The verdict also means the judge will determine and award compensatory damages in the coming weeks.

The harassment verdict was expected after the jury sent a note to the judge Monday indicating it believed Thomas, the Garden and Dolan sexually harassed Browne Sanders, a married mother of three and former vice president for marketing.

Browne Sanders is currently an associate athletic director and senior woman administrator at the University of Buffalo.

"All of us in the Division of Athletics are thrilled to know that Anucha has been vindicated and that both her and her family have wrapped up this very difficult ordeal,'' the university said in a statement. "We look forward to seeing her soon and, most of all, are elated that she can move on with her life and career.''

The jurors had heard Browne Sanders testify that Thomas, after arriving as new team president, routinely addressed her as "bitch'' and "ho'' in outbursts over marketing commitments. He later did an abrupt about-face, declaring his love and suggesting an "off-site'' liaison, she said.

Thomas, while admitting to using foul language around the plaintiff, insisted he never directed it toward her.

Degrading a woman in the workplace "is never OK,'' said Thomas, a married father of two. "It is never appropriate.''

Dolan and a string of other executives also took the witness stand to deny they tolerated or witnessed sexual harassment. They testified Browne Sanders was fired because she was incompetent on budget matters, and because she later sought to undermine an internal inquiry into her allegations against Thomas.

The trial also made headlines with its testimony about an admitted tryst involving star Knicks guard Stephon Marbury and an MSG intern, an encounter the plaintiffs' attorneys argued demonstrated the organization's frat house mentality.

At the Knicks training camp in South Carolina on Tuesday, Marbury and other players said it was time for the team to move past the off-court controversy. Thomas was expected to arrive Wednesday.

"It's a tough situation and the only thing we can do now is go forward,'' Marbury said.

Forward Malik Rose predicted the team would rally behind Dolan and Thomas.

"We all know what kind of guy 'Mr. D' is,'' he said before the jury awarded punitive damages. "We all know what kind of guy Isiah is and how they treat us. I'm sure all you guys agree this is a first-class organization.''

MSG is owned by Cablevision Systems Corp., based in Bethpage, N.Y., and Dolan is Cablevision's CEO. Shares fell 35 cents, or 1 percent, to $34.71 in afternoon trading.

Insert photo of Browne Sanders from 1010 WINS' Juliet Papa

More Manhattan news...


(TM & © 2007 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO & EYE Logo TM & © 2007 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report. In the interest of timeliness, this story is fed directly from the newswire and may contain occasional typographical errors. )
Show Comments
 
 
10/02/2007 11:46AM
Thomas Verdict
A jury ruled Tuesday that New York Knicks coach Isiah Thomas sexually harassed a former top team executive, subjecting her to unwanted advances and a barrage of verbal insults, but also ruled he does not have to pay punitive damages. Agree with their ruling?
10/02/2007 11:53AM
yes
I think Thomas is a dog! you go girl
10/02/2007 11:57AM
Tony
I agree with the ruling by the jury and I also believe that Isiah must be fired. In any other industry, he would be fired if found guilty of sexual harassment. He must be fired as Knicks coach and President immediately.
10/02/2007 12:03PM
yes squared
That's an insult to dogs. Thomas is a pig....a stupid pig!
10/02/2007 12:05PM
Thomas Verdict
yes. thomas and msg will pay for their rank behavior
10/02/2007 12:05PM
Thin Line
I don't think she validated her case enough to receive punitive damages. The high profile cases have a way of rising to the top. I personally, have endured far more abuse on the job, but as a common man, I had no grounds to take the firm to task. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, celebrity status doesn't dictate who is and isn't /abused/harrased/attacked, and I am reserving my personal judgement, but I'm sure Isiah could have easily found someone else to approach, rather than jeopardize his career, and reputation. Just another tabloid victory in my book. I only wish the law fought for the ordinary working "Joe" as effectively as it did in this case.
10/02/2007 12:05PM
Isiah Verdict
He got railroaded by a money thieving goldigger. Bad decision!!!
10/02/2007 12:06PM
YES!
It is refreshing that she won over the "big boys" that were so careless thinking who they are will allow them to get away with just about anything. Think again you cocky sueudo macho nothings!
10/02/2007 12:09PM
Fantastic News!!!!
Vindication for all those who use thier power to harrass co-workers.
10/02/2007 12:25PM
You go girl
I'm happy with the verdict and I hope Thomas get fired for this stupid stunt. I'm confuse, you find MSG liable but not Thomas. He was was the individual who was sexually harassing Ms. Brown-Saunders and not MSG. MSG was just the company who closes his eye to the corruption. I'm still Happy for the outcome. I wish the Knicks well for this up coming season, because it will affect their spirit. I;m still a Knicks fan. Sybrandt.
10/02/2007 12:27PM
Way to Go
the Garden is an embarrassment a/k/a James Dolan
10/02/2007 12:29PM
Money Does Crazy Thigs
He was a victim of a woman who was only out for the money and nothing else she did not prove her case enough and the defense provided enough information to prove that she was not doing her job to a satisfactory condition
10/02/2007 12:29PM
Good!
For years, Thomas tried to get by on that stupid grin of his. A lot of people, fans and media brought into it. Maybe now they'll realize what idiots they were. Congratulations to the jury for coming to this right conclusion for Sanders.
10/02/2007 12:35PM
Lame!
We all know that this was a unfair verdict. The Plantiff is a 350 lb unattractive wildabeast and Isiah Thomas being as good looking as he is and who can probably get any piece of ass he wanted would never bother or harras this woman for sex #1. Secondly I belive that having 4 woman on the jury panel definetly influenced this unfair descision. Its ashame that this woman got away with this and received a descion..
10/02/2007 12:35PM
Great Verdict
Now Isiah & Fat Jimmy can sing the blues together. Losers, just like the Knicks. Perfect.
10/02/2007 12:37PM
NotYourBusiness
Did he behave in a stupid way? Yes. Did she take advantage of it to cash in? You bet. I, for one, wouldn't mind a bit of harassment for $10M. Wouldn't you?
10/02/2007 12:39PM
Former MSG Employee
Dolan rules that place like a 5 year old put in charge of a sandbox. All its problems trickle down from him and the lack of understanding he has towards how a business should run. He is no Charles. He is just Jimmy.
10/02/2007 12:39PM
Unjust
Yes...an unjust verdict ONLY because Thomas wasn't made to pay damages. Thomas should be fired immediatelt both for his harassment and his racially dividing remarks !
10/02/2007 12:42PM
Brown Sanders
Brown Sanders held a key position with IBM before going to work at the Garden. While at IBM she was held in the highest regard as an honest, hard-working employee. Referring to her as a "goldigger" is ignorant. Do your homework...
10/02/2007 12:43PM
its about time
MSG has taken advantage of fans for years. Start paying back season ticket holders.
10/02/2007 12:45PM
another rediculous verdict
This woman is just another disgruntled employee attempting to get $$. I hope the verdict is overturned. They should countersue!!
10/02/2007 12:48PM
bad language is not
sorry folks bad language in the work place does not harrasment make. sad the lady is so angry at the world and poor innnocent people must pay for it .
10/02/2007 12:53PM
Mr SP
The Jury guilty verdict send the wrong message. She presented no evidence to boost her case. The jury went for the under dog, not by the facts presented during the trial. I did not find her credible. They should had came with a not guilty verdict.
10/02/2007 12:56PM
Go get your money.
Girl, go get that money. Making them pay hits them harder then you think.
10/02/2007 12:58PM
Down With the Good-Old-Boys-Club
Kiss your wives and not you female executives. Start bringing your wives to the games. And not just holding their hands for your court cases. Sensitivity training should be given to all MSG executives.
10/02/2007 1:04PM
About time
Everyone can see it but thomas and dolan. Now he is a loser in court and on the court.
10/02/2007 1:17PM
Rising Rate
Ok now we will se all the pricing of cablevision services go up as a result
10/02/2007 1:24PM
That SLIME BAG
He got what he deserves.... Justice is GREAT.....
10/02/2007 1:25PM
tramp
she's not a ho, she's a low class tramp, an opportunist, and got away with it. all about money and revenge. move over britney, there's new trailer trash to rival your actions.
10/02/2007 1:28PM
Concentrate on the Knicks
Mr Thomas should have concentrated on his team and not his co-worker. Its Kobe Bryant all over again! Do you job and leave the female employees alone!
10/02/2007 1:34PM
Just look at her
Let her take a lie detector, stupid bitch.
10/02/2007 1:49PM
Were you there...
I am taking a wild guess that all those who claim the woman did not prove her case were NOT in the courtrrom to hear the evidence. Nes pas?
10/02/2007 2:00PM
so what about the guys
so when are men going to win 11.6 million dollars for being sexually harrassed? huh?
10/02/2007 2:04PM
NO
YES BLACK TO BLACK ONLY IN AMERICA IN FOR THE MONEY WHY NOT SUE RIGHT AFTER SHE GOT CANNNNNED JUST LIES
10/02/2007 2:05PM
Vamp not Tramp Sucker!
She presented her case and won, Bravo Mrs. Sanders...And to all the men that think she lie...the jury obviously believed otherwise...
10/02/2007 2:05PM
Agree 100%
They should have awarded full 20 mil
10/02/2007 2:08PM
NuYorker
What you sport around comes back to haunt you. MSG will have the 11 million dollar fine reduced on appeal just enough to pay all of her lawyers. The Lawyers always get paid. I would'ny count on that money ever being spent on a new swimming pool!!!
10/02/2007 2:09PM
Respect the Black Woman
Ms. Brown deserves every penny and more. I applaud her for taking a stand.
10/02/2007 2:20PM
Investment counselor
....call me!
10/02/2007 2:22PM
REDICULOUS
ID BE WILLING TO BE CALLED A BITCH FOR 11.6 MIL. WHATS THIS WORLD COMING TO? THIS DECISION IS AN INSULT TO ALL THE INTELLIGENT PEOPLE OUT THERE AND JUST REAFFIRMS TO THE IDIOTS OUT THERE THAT ALL THEY NEED TO DO TO BECOME RICH IS TO SUE CORPORATE AMERICA.
10/02/2007 2:25PM
confused
How can a jury find in favor of Ms Brown-Sanders and not award punitive damages against Isiah. The jury could not agree on an award from Thomas but agreed that MSG & Dolan should pay. Wasn't it Isiah who committed the Harassment. Something is not right
10/02/2007 2:26PM
Now hiring...
...um..where may I sign up for the job, please?
10/02/2007 2:40PM
Paid for being sub-par at work and being unattractive
This really sucks. She just hit the lottery pending an appeals. Obviously she could not do her job correctly and exacted revenge or had her hand out. Being called a bitch is so ridiculous. There are tons of women called worst who deserve something. This thing has now screwed up any chance of any other QUALIFIED woman of ever getting a job there and probably elsewhere. The thing may have deserved about 2 million but no more. Isiah should have his head examined if he actually tried to hit up on it. She cracks every mirror around there. God help us now!
10/02/2007 2:44PM
What about her job?
She wanted her job back and back pay originally. If you were being harassed so badly why would you want your job back in the first place? Secondly there are some industries where women are moving up . Stick to WNBA maybe they will hire her.
10/02/2007 2:45PM
Justice is served!
Isiah must go - and take Stephan w/you as well. The Knicks need to get back some respectability! Isiah has drag the team's reputation down the gutter!!!
10/02/2007 2:47PM
I've been there...
No amt of money compensates for the disrespect of sexual harrassment. For all the ladies who have endured in order to earn a living, FINALLY YEA!
10/02/2007 3:02PM
Bad, bad management
It's time say hello -- to the BROOKLYN NETS! There's so much $$$ in the business, that they can throw it away & make awful decisions... it makes them feel all-powerful, to get away with it (month after month). What this does, is re-affirm that you HAVE to use better judgment about carelessly using language etc. (really? who kisses people hello that aren't attractive -- right? is Isiah kissing older ladies & men at that, everyday? no). This is the organization that ran The Wiz into the ground, had to pay what, $28 million in one lump sum to Larry Johnson and gave another former player over $100 million in an absurd contract in Allan Houston... and made Who Knows how many other blunders? BUT THE $$$ keeps rolling in... maybe the L.I. cable users get a increase, to make up the $11.6 and another $500k of legal fees?
10/02/2007 3:12PM
Pu-lease
If she is such a high ranking executive, she aught to be able to put a punk like Isiah in his place without resorting to the legal system. To a certain point, it is a woman's responsibility to set boundries. This particular case seems like alot of B.S. for $$$
10/02/2007 3:25PM
Enough is enough
I can't believe how many people out there just assume they know what actually happened and didn't happen. What we just witnessed is someone claim some things happened to her and next to nothing to collaborate any of it so how does that equal proof? It happened because she said so? What we do know is she abused her power to in forcing that intern to go public w/ a personal matter w/ no regard for her right to privacy b/c her main objective was to assasinate the character of the people she worked with and for and it worked? This is a sad day for the justice system in this country. You can't just go around handing down guilty verdicts based on gut feelings because gut feelings usually = prejudices. Isiah has come under fire in the NY media w/ regard to his job performance with the Knicks and isn't that beloved a figure by the media and unfortunately most people's opinions are shaped by what they read and hear. Even during the trial you couldn't come across an objective article outside of the NY Times or ESPN.com. Daily News, NY Post forget about it, it was all one sided coverage and it isn't right. People act like 10 million isn't a motive to lie. One question to all the people that agree with this verdict; where is the proof?
10/02/2007 3:29PM
Are you people kidding?
By reading some of these ignorant comments, I can certainly see why women, in this day and age, still have to fight the battle of harrassment in the workplace. I applaud Ms. Brown Sanders for taking on the good old boys network! Obviously, she is an intelligent hard-working woman, or they wouldn't have hired her in the first place. This isn't about the money - it's about respect. Maybe some of you should pay closer attention instead of slinging insults.....
10/02/2007 3:53PM
Justice!!!!
I agree with the verdict. James Dolan, Isiah and Stephen - you guys are an embarrassment to New York City. You have brought the Knicks/MSG n all-time low. You're a disgrace to your family and friends. PLEASE GO AWAY...FAR AWAY...DISAPPEAR OFF THE FACE OF THE EARTH!!!!
10/02/2007 3:59PM
The Jury Spoke
James Dolan should of never of let it get to this point. It shows what a rinky dink outfit MSG is and how it's run. His father must be fuming and humiliated by James behavior. Isiah it's time for you to go away.The Knicks to be totaly rebuilt and away from you. This jerk wanted to buy the Yankees Oh my God the Boss would of had a heasrt attack
10/02/2007 4:18PM
DONNY
He never has struck me as the sharpest knife in the drawer. And now he has highlighted not only his ignorance but that of his employer and especially Jim Dolan. Mazel Tov Ms. Brown
10/02/2007 4:28PM
Paybacks
They are a bit__. And Jim knows EXACTLY what I am talking about. For someone who knew him when, take it from me, he is a moron. The whole company has been trashed by Jim. And, Thomas is a playuh. Full- fledged.
10/02/2007 4:36PM
SAD
Hard working Americans have suffered and endured far more real pain, real suffering. Name calling does not justify millions, Sorry. I think anyone here would take a little work place harrasment easily for far less a jackpot A sad day for working people.
10/02/2007 4:50PM
IGNORANCE
James Dolan, Isiah Thomas and MSG got socked and they deserved it. Who fires someone in the middle of a sexual harassment complaint investigation. Ral bright.
10/02/2007 4:55PM
1049
you go dolan pay up ol boy
10/02/2007 5:03PM
shanty
what goes around comes around
10/02/2007 5:19PM
BIGJOE
GOLDDIGGER.......
10/02/2007 5:19PM
james dolan
i offered her $300k to go away quote unquote
10/02/2007 5:26PM
NuYorker
She will never see this money unless an agreement is reached before appeal. An appeal can take 7-10 years in our clogged court system.
10/02/2007 5:30PM
put chuck in charge
jim is not qualified to fix a sandwich
10/02/2007 5:33PM
layoffs
cable employees layoffs will be an order
10/02/2007 5:41PM
chuck
sorry jim i gave you some resposibilitys that i thought you can handle time for papa charles to take back over the company going forward
10/02/2007 6:55PM
All About Money
$11 million bucks for what?? A few insults? Beyond Rediculous!
Title:
Comment:
Print Page Email This Page
Featured Audio
Money Markets and More for Tuesday, October 14
Is it now safe for individual investors to jump back into the stock market? Are we out of the woods? A guru is skeptical about the Treasury banking plan. And what would Jackie Gleason think of Monday’s amazing rally?
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
News Watch

Weddings
Find Wedding Locations, Wedding Photography, Bridal Expo, and other wedding resources in the New York area from PartyPOP.com